| 1972/73 1’s | 1974/75 2’s | 1975/76 3’s |
| Mark Cockburn (Capt) | | John Harvey | | Peter Pearson | | David Burgin | | Andrew Goddard | | Gary Arnott | | Terry Davis | | Kevin Phelan | | Mark Pearson | | Peter Mitchell | | Adrian Byrne | | | Brian Cusack (Capt) | | John Harvey | | Mick Brandon | | Rod Sheldon | | Tony Isaacs | | David Burgin | | Peter Rackham | | Peter Mitchell | | Mick Podbury | | Bernie Pattison | | Robert Phelan | | | Graham Pratt (Capt) | | Greg Hogan | | Alan Jones | | Peter Rackham | | Geoff Underwood | | Paul Kavanagh | | Peter Kavanagh | | Brendan Davis | | Gerard Mahoney | | Mark Pearson | | Harry Pratt | |
| 1977/78 2’s | 1978/79 3’s | 1985/86 1’s |
| Brian Cusack (Capt) | | Frank Bottomley | | Jeff James | | Rod Sheldon | | Tony Isaacs | | George Conlan | | Robert Phelan | | Mick Podbury | | Peter Moulton | | Anthony Smith | | ?? | | | Bill O’Callaghan (Capt) | | Vince McGartland | | Greg Blanck | | Frank Monaghan | | John Pearson | | Tim Doran | | Brendan Davis | | Chris James | | Gerard McCartney | | Kornel Dachs | | Brian Cusack | | | Mick Laidler (Capt) | | Terry Davis | | Jack O’Connell | | Mick Redmond | | Paul Hedley | | Paul Hughes | | Mick Finlay | | John Serrano | | Dean Solomon | | Rod Moulton | | Greg Sebire | |
| 1985/86 2’s | 1985/86 3’s | 1987/88 2’s |
| Tony Isaacs (Capt) | | John Legge-Wilkinson | | Stewie McGurn | | Julian Kennelly | | Chris Wade | | Dave Norton | | Rob Smith | | Mick Powell | | Brett Mahoney | | Merv Cussen | | Paul Sheedy | | | Ed Sait (Capt) | | Brian Roche | | David Vosti | | Laurie Cloonan | | Phil Conlan | | Gerard McCartney | | Peter Monaghan | | Brendan Dillon | | Peter Kelly | | Kornel Dachs | | Steve Cameron | | | Tony Isaacs (Capt) | | Tim Carroll | | Michael Davis | | Stewie McGurn | | Paul Hughes | | Steve McLeod | | Gerard McCartney | | Michael Deasy | | Mick Powell | | Adam Djokovic | | Dirk Andrichem | |
| 1988/89 1’s | 1990/91 1’s | 1993/94 3’s |
| Mick Laidler (Capt) | | Mick Redmond | | Richard Laidler | | Terry Davis | | Michael Davis | | Tim Carroll | | Stewie McGurn | | John Serrano | | Rod Moulton | | Dean Solomon | | Gerard McCartney | | | Leigh Aitken (Capt) | | Mick Redmond | | Terry Davis | | Michael Davis | | David Bartholomeusz | | Steve McLeod | | Stewie McGurn | | John Serrano | | Chris Hoyne | | Dean Solomon | | Paul Sheedy | | | Laurie Cloonan (Capt) | | Brett Mahoney | | Kevin Mahady | | Jim Maynard | | Dennis Huxley | | Tim Foster | | Brendan Dillon | | Brett Arthur | | Mick Szabo | | Luke Beaumont | Brian Roche | |
| 2002/03 3’s | 2003/04 2’s | 2003/04 3’s |
| Duncan Hefter (Capt) | | Ross Rodgers | | Paul Fitzgerald | | Dan Jordan | | Rob Vosti | | Shaun Wilkinson | | Ivan Jurcic | | Michael Deasy | | Wes Strang | | Glenn Took | | Tony O’Neill | | | Jason Bourke (Capt) | | Anthony Jordan | | Anthony Garvey | | Andre Noonan | | Luke Carmichael | | Dan Jordan | | Brad Maiden | | Andrew Boag | | Michael Knight | | Daniel Sheehan | | Luke Davis | | | Shaun Wilkinson (Capt) | | Grant McKenzie | | Ross Rodgers | | Nick Serrano | | Ivan Jurcic | | John Jordan | | Chris Baumgartner | | Tristan Kassis | | Daniel Serrano | | Duncan Hefter | | Michael Di Natale | |
| 2005/06 2’s | 2007/08 2’s | 2008/09 1’s |
| Jason Bourke (Capt) | | Anthony Garvey | | Luke Wilson | | Andre Noonan | | Nick Serrano | | Anthony Jordan | | Tristan Kassis | | Andrew Boag | | Tim Raffle | | Michael Di Natale | | Luke Davis | | | Anthony Jordan (Capt) | | Tom Overman | | Jason Bourke | | Michael Vallence | | Nick Serrano | | Nick Frayne | | Greg Garth | | Simon Cave | | Michael Di Natale | | Rex Bennett | | Sinclair Johansen | | | Craig Osborne (Capt) | | Gary McIntyre | | Ivan Jurcic | | Anthony Jordan | | Chris Spinella | | Tristan Kassis | | Antonio Mullins | | Jordan Mills | | Simon Cave | | Chris Davis | | Luke Davis | |
| 2008/09 2’s | 2013/14 3’s | |
| Michael Vallence (Capt) | | James Davey | | Jason Bourke | | Andrew Drowley | | Anthony Garvey | | Greg Garth | | Nick Serrano | | Mark Castles | | Michael Di Natale | | Liam Jilla | | Rex Bennett | | | Brendan Davey (Capt) | | Jason Bourke | | Henry Jaggard | | Anthony Jordan | | Blake Manassa | | Ryan Scarborough | | Michael Wheaton | | Tom Isaacs | | James Riley | | James Browne | | Jamie Bialecki | | |